Skip to content
Module 07 of 1260 min readBeginner

Sales and trading

Equities, fixed income, currencies, commodities (FICC). Market making vs flow vs structured. Prop trading and what the Volcker Rule did to it. How a desk actually makes money.

58%

Listen along

Read “Sales and trading” aloud

Plays in your browser using on-device text-to-speech — nothing leaves the page.

Learning objectives

By the end of this module, you should be able to:

  • 01Distinguish equities from FICC (Fixed Income, Currencies, Commodities) and the sub-desks within each
  • 02Explain the difference between sales coverage, market-making, and proprietary trading
  • 03Analyse the impact of the Volcker Rule on bank prop trading and the rise of Citadel Securities, Jane Street, and Hudson River
  • 04Understand how a market-making desk earns its bid-ask spread and manages inventory risk

Sales and trading — S&T or 'the floor' — is the business of buying and selling securities and derivatives for the bank's institutional clients. The two big silos are equities and FICC (Fixed Income, Currencies, Commodities). Within each, sub-desks specialise by product: cash equities, equity derivatives, prime services, and program trading on the equity side; rates, credit, FX, emerging markets, and commodities on the FICC side.

The sales side

The sales side is client-facing. Sales coverage maintains relationships with institutional buyers and sellers — hedge funds, mutual funds, pension plans, insurance companies, sovereign wealth funds. Salespeople pitch trade ideas, take orders, market new issues, and feed flow information back to the trading desk. They are paid on production credits — a complex internal system that allocates revenue to the people who originated each trade.

The trading side

Trading is the book-runner. Traders make markets — quoting bid and ask prices that clients can hit or lift — and manage the risk of the resulting positions. A market-making desk earns the bid-ask spread on flow and tries to hedge or unwind inventory before the market moves. Profitable market making requires deep knowledge of order flow, fast risk management, and the willingness to take inventory positions clients want to offload.

The Volcker Rule and the end of prop

Before the 2010 Volcker Rule (a Dodd-Frank provision implementing a ban on US bank proprietary trading), large parts of S&T were proprietary — traders deployed the bank's own capital to take outright positions on directional and relative-value views. The Volcker Rule largely ended that, with carve-outs for market making and underwriting. Banks have continued to take positions disguised as 'inventory' but the scale has come down dramatically. Genuine prop trading now lives at hedge funds and at firms like Citadel Securities, Jane Street, and Hudson River Trading, which have eaten much of the market-making business banks used to dominate.

S&T compensation is heavily formulaic. A senior trader on a profitable desk can earn $5-15M+ in a strong year; the same trader on a losing desk can be cut at year-end. The pay-for-performance structure is sharper than IBD, and the variance is correspondingly higher.

FICC is much larger than equities by revenue. The FX market alone trades $7+ trillion a day; rates and credit add multiples of that. The largest banks (JPM, Goldman, Citi, BofA, Morgan Stanley, Barclays, Deutsche, BNP) all run global FICC franchises, though the post-2008 era has seen consolidation, with European banks pulling back and the top US banks gaining share.

Exercise

The CFO of a Kenyan corporate calls a sales coverage at Stanbic and asks: 'I want to sell USD 50m worth of Kenyan T-bonds maturing 2034 — what's your best bid?' Walk through what happens between the CFO's call and the trade executing. Who quotes the price? Where does the risk go? How does the bank make money? And how is the bank's risk managed if the market moves before the bonds can be on-sold?

Key takeaways

  • FICC dwarfs equities — the FX market alone trades $7tn+ per day; rates and credit add multiples of that
  • The Volcker Rule (2010 Dodd-Frank) ended most proprietary trading at US banks; market-making and underwriting carve-outs remain
  • Sales runs on production credits — a complex internal allocation of revenue to whoever originated each trade
  • Trader pay-for-performance is sharper than IBD: $5-15M+ in a strong year for senior traders, but losing desks get cut at year-end

Further reading

  1. 01

    A Demon of Our Own Design: Markets, Hedge Funds, and the Perils of Financial Innovation

    Richard Bookstaber · Wiley · 2007

  2. 02

    Flash Boys: A Wall Street Revolt

    Michael Lewis · W. W. Norton · 2014On the rise of HFT and the changing structure of equities trading.

  3. 03
Loading progress…
LeadAfrikPublic Economics Hub